Man Utd Player Report: Newcastle Game

Zacong

You need 3 min read

·

Post on Dec 31, 2024

37 visitor like this post

Share

Man Utd Player Report: Newcastle United Domination and Defensive Fragility Exposed

Manchester United's trip to St. James' Park ended in a frustrating 2-0 defeat against a dominant Newcastle United side. While the Red Devils showed glimpses of attacking promise, defensive vulnerabilities and a lack of cutting edge ultimately cost them. Let's delve into individual player performances:

Goalkeepers:

• Andre Onana: While not directly at fault for either goal, Onana couldn't prevent Newcastle's well-taken efforts. He made a couple of important saves, showcasing his agility and shot-stopping ability, but overall, he was a spectator for large portions of the match. His distribution was also slightly erratic at times. Rating: 6/10

Defenders:

• Aaron Wan-Bissaka: Wan-Bissaka's defensive solidity was evident, particularly in the first half. However, he offered little going forward and his attacking contributions remained minimal. Newcastle's dominance down their left flank consistently put him under pressure. Rating: 6.5/10
• Lisandro Martinez: Martinez, as usual, battled hard in the heart of the defense, displaying his aggressive tackling style. However, he was occasionally caught out of position, highlighting the overall defensive frailties. He contributed little in the attacking phase. Rating: 6/10
• Victor Lindelof: Lindelof looked shaky at times and struggled to cope with Newcastle's physicality. He was partially culpable for at least one of the goals, failing to adequately deal with a cross into the box. Rating: 5.5/10
• Luke Shaw: Shaw offered more going forward than Wan-Bissaka, providing some dangerous crosses. However, defensively, he was also exposed on several occasions, highlighting the team's struggle to deal with Newcastle’s attacking prowess. Rating: 6/10

Midfielders:

• Casemiro: Casemiro worked tirelessly in midfield, but lacked the creative spark needed to unlock Newcastle's stubborn defence. His usual defensive prowess was somewhat muted by Newcastle's superior midfield control. Rating: 6.5/10
• Mason Mount: Mount's performance was inconsistent. He showed flashes of brilliance with some clever passes and runs but failed to translate those into significant goal-scoring opportunities. He needs to find more consistency. Rating: 6/10
• Bruno Fernandes: Fernandes was relatively quiet by his high standards. He struggled to exert his usual influence on the game and lacked the cutting edge in the final third. Rating: 6/10

Forwards:

• Antony: Antony's pace and dribbling ability were evident, but his final ball often lacked accuracy. He failed to truly test the Newcastle goalkeeper and his overall contribution was disappointing. Rating: 5.5/10
• Marcus Rashford: Rashford, while lively, was largely ineffective against Newcastle's resolute defense. He created little and didn't look as threatening as he has in previous games. Rating: 6/10
• Alejandro Garnacho (Substitute): Garnacho added some much-needed attacking impetus when he came on. His direct running caused problems for the Newcastle defense, showcasing his potential. Rating: 7/10

Overall:

The loss to Newcastle exposed several key weaknesses within the Manchester United squad. The team's defensive fragility was alarming, while the lack of creativity and cutting edge in the final third proved costly. Individual performances were largely uninspiring, with the exception of Garnacho's late cameo. Manager Erik ten Hag will need to address these issues quickly to avoid further setbacks. The team needs to find a better balance between attack and defence, and improve their ability to break down stubborn opposition.