Man Utd Player Ratings Vs Newcastle

Zacong

You need 3 min read

·

Post on Dec 31, 2024

35 visitor like this post

Share

Man Utd Player Ratings: A Dismal Display Against Newcastle

Manchester United's recent clash against Newcastle United ended in a disappointing 2-0 defeat, leaving fans and pundits alike questioning the team's performance. Let's delve into the individual player ratings, analyzing their contributions (or lack thereof) in this lackluster showing at St. James' Park.

Goalkeeper:

• Andre Onana (6/10): While Onana couldn't prevent both goals, he made several crucial saves that prevented a heavier defeat. His distribution was, as usual, a strength, but he was ultimately let down by the defensive line.

Defenders:

• Aaron Wan-Bissaka (5/10): Struggled to contain Newcastle's attacking threat down the left flank. His forward runs offered little and his defensive work was consistently underwhelming.
• Raphael Varane (5.5/10): A relatively quiet game for Varane, but not in a positive sense. While he made some important tackles, he seemed hesitant at times and was caught out of position leading to Newcastle’s attacking opportunities.
• Lisandro Martínez (5/10): Like Varane, Martínez had a frustrating evening. He struggled with Newcastle's physicality and his usually precise passing lacked accuracy.
• Luke Shaw (6/10): The best of the back four, Shaw provided some decent attacking overlaps and showed more commitment defensively. However, he was still exposed on occasion by Newcastle's counter-attacks.

Midfielders:

• Casemiro (6.5/10): As always, Casemiro was a tireless worker in midfield, winning back possession diligently. However, his impact on the game was limited due to United's overall struggles. He lacked his usual creative spark and incisive passing.
• Mason Mount (5.5/10): Failed to make much of an impact. His creative abilities were stifled, and he offered little defensively. A disappointing performance from the summer signing.
• Bruno Fernandes (5/10): A surprisingly subdued performance from the captain. His usual flair was missing, and his decision-making was often questionable. He needs to take more responsibility to improve the team's attacking play.

Forwards:

• Marcus Rashford (6/10): One of the few players to show any significant attacking threat. He was lively, attempting several runs, but the service to him was often lacking. He could have done better with the opportunities created.
• Antony (5/10): Another disappointing showing. His dribbling skills were visible, but his final ball was consistently poor. He needs to improve his decision-making and consistency.
• Alejandro Garnacho (6.5/10): Garnacho offered some pace and urgency after coming on. While he couldn't find the back of the net, his energy was much-needed.

Substitutes:

• Jadon Sancho (6/10): Offered a threat on the wing with his pace, but lacked the killer instinct in the final third.
• Scott McTominay (N/A): Didn't play long enough to warrant a rating.

Overall:

The team performance was far from their best. Individual errors and a lack of cohesion in various parts of the pitch contributed significantly to the defeat. Several key players underperformed, highlighting the need for improvement in both tactical approach and individual execution. The game exposed a vulnerability against physical and organized opponents. Manager Erik ten Hag needs to find solutions to address the team’s defensive and attacking woes. This match serves as a wake-up call and provides a valuable lesson for a team with higher ambitions. The need for improvements is glaring and needs to be addressed quickly.